which is the bigger qb trade mistake?

[TonyGraziani]

Us trading Brett Favre or the Bucs trading Steve Young? Both are hof'ers, but I doubt either makes it if they stayed in their original cities. Jus tryna start some good football conversation. Thoughts?

[Radical]

Favre would have drank himself out of the league here.

[ChrisD]

Is there a McNabb to Washington option anywhere?

Bucs trading Young was way worse.

[atl falcon 89]

Gotta say I might get a negative out of this but in the long run it might be us trading Farve. The Bucs were able (many years later) to still get a Superbowl ring, while we're still waiting on ours .(and don't worry its coming)

[TonyGraziani]

(09-21-2010 12:11 AM)Radical Wrote:  Favre would have drank himself out of the league here.

Or so I've heard. That was before my time. But Young wouldn't have been given the reins to a SB champ team in Tampa. So does he still become THE Steve Young?

[Radical]

(09-21-2010 12:16 AM)TonyGraziani Wrote:  Or so I've heard. That was before my time. But Young wouldn't have been given the reins to a SB champ team in Tampa. So does he still become THE Steve Young?

No, but he may have done something with him. Favre would be working at the wal-mart or dead in a back alley somewhere here.

[TonyGraziani]

(09-21-2010 12:17 AM)Radical Wrote:  No, but he may have done something with him. Favre would be working at the wal-mart or dead in a back alley somewhere here.

You're probably right. Anyone know why they traded him? Did he show anything when he was there?

[DaMeatTrough]

Schaubby

[NZFalcon]

(09-21-2010 12:22 AM)TonyGraziani Wrote:  You're probably right. Anyone know why they traded him? Did he show anything when he was there?

something like 5 pass no completions 2 INT and his first pass being a pick6

[TonyGraziani]

(09-21-2010 12:32 AM)DaMeatTrough Wrote:  Schaubby

I still say that was a great trade. If we walked outta that draft with Pat Willis and Sidney Rice (like I wanted)you would say the same. Let's not use revisionist history.