which is the bigger qb trade mistake?

[Magic Man]

I think the Bucs...it's been well documented by Brett that his rise had solely to do with getting out of the "A" and going to a city that shuts down at ten like Green Bay.

[NCFalconfan]

I base my opinion on which one given the choice could I have on my team in their prime and that would be Steve Young.

[keithbrooking56]

I still do not understand how people blame the Falcons for trading Favre. From former coaches, front office personnel and Favre **himself** they all admit he cared more about partying and drinking than football. Favre HIMSELF said he would have been out of the NFL in no time had he stayed in Atlanta. The best thing they ever did for him was trade him to a tiny town with no night life like Green Bay freakin' Wisconsin.

None of those things apply to Steve Young who had already showed his mettle in the USFL (just like Jim Kelly) and was ready to be a franchise QB for years.