Vince Young wins the 2005 Heisman!

[Muskokas Finest]

Not defending Reggie Bush one bit, but the Heisman Trust and it's trophy should not be a tool in the battle between the NCAA and USC

[swanlee]

(09-22-2010 10:49 AM)Muskokas Finest Wrote:  Not defending Reggie Bush one bit, but the Heisman Trust and it's trophy should not be a tool in the battle between the NCAA and USC

The Heisman doesn't even seem to mean much anymore, the winners are often busts in the NFL.

[Muskokas Finest]

(09-22-2010 10:58 AM)swanlee Wrote:  The Heisman doesn't even seem to mean much anymore, the winners are often busts in the NFL.

Heisman is still the "it" award in college football. It's winners dominant the game and are not in any way judged by how their skills might translate to the NFL

[Statick]

(09-22-2010 09:57 AM)Jesus Wrote:  What Bush did had nothing to do with what happened on the field. It was a classy move for him to return the Heisman but he earned it.

I disagree. What he did on the field was moot. He wasn't qualified to be out there in the first place due to what he did off the field.