That was a disco move, not a football move....

[AsylumGuido]

(01-01-2011 09:34 AM)Beef Wrote:  Well I don't believe that's fair, but that's just my opinion, you have yours.

Doing the down over makes the last play ridiculously lopsided with regards to punishment for the 2 infractions & that doesn't seem right to me. One side benefitted greatly & the other got totally screwed on what's supposed to be equal punishment.

I'm sure that if Greer would have intercepted the ball & it was reveresed because of the ruling, that all of bagheadville would have raised holy hell about how they got screwed too. And I'd be sitting here saying I agree with them.

You are incredible. In my 45+ years of following football I couldn't count how many times offsetting penalties have resulted in a positive play for my team being called back. You are the first person in my life that I have ever seen their panties get in such a wad over it, though. I have no doubt it is sour grapes. You are obviously grasping for some straw to explain why your team lost. I can assure you that New Orleans fans wouldn't be raising holy hell if it had been the other way around. They would have simply accepted it as part of the game.

The same rule applies in college ball and in high school. You are unreal.

Does anyone out there think that Beef is making any sense?