Threaded Mode | Linear Mode

illmusic · 05-03-2011, 03:09 PM

(05-03-2011 01:48 PM)phalcon phil Wrote: If we are going by just RIGHT NOW, yes i would put schaub over mcnabb, but if we are going RIGHT NOW then we also have to say that vick is better than ryan flacco schaub roethlisberger rivers as well. you cant dispute that.

i was just stating overall between now and what theyve accomplished over the years.

i must apologize. when i see obvious toolery occurring i must step in even if it makes me seem like im bashing the team. nothing better than breaking up a circle jerk with facts. lol

Vick is better than Rivers? Lol, hell, Vick was better than Rivers this year?! Lololol

Dale4Saul2Red0 · (This post was last modified: 05-03-2011 03:13 PM by Dale4Saul2Red0.)

^

Vick better than Rivers is silly on a whole new level. Wasn't Vick's best season last year and it still didn't touch Rivers. Vick better than Roethlisberger? HOW??? Rings don't lie and neither do clutch performances.

You actually can't say Vick is clearly better than any of those guys. I think Roeth and Rivers are above everyone PhalconPhil mentioned with everyone else basically on the same level right now. Picking one over the other would be splitting hairs and they are all at different points in their careers too. Also I don't think 1 season from Vick should put him on that level. He faded last year. His type of QB takes a beating all season long and Vick is smaller than some of you realize. So my question to you is what good is a QB if he can't play his best football towards the end of the year because of the constant beating he takes?

**atljbo** · 05-03-2011, 03:14 PM

(05-03-2011 03:08 PM)Swift Is a Die Hard Wrote: Its hard to say cause his main body of work is not complete yet but he has potential to be in top 3 ..If Jones turns out to be a bust and we lose and not make playoffs next 2 years and the $$ we poured into those teams and 0 playoff wins in 5 years (hypothetical ) how can we say he was a successful GM

If the moves pay off and we have playoff success or a Super Bowl within next 2 years
I will easily say TD is one of the best GMS in the league

I can take that

Swift Is a Die Hard · 05-03-2011, 03:17 PM

(05-03-2011 03:14 PM)atljbo Wrote: I can take that

Im not that hard to get along with and im pretty fair ..

illmusic · 05-03-2011, 03:18 PM

(05-03-2011 03:11 PM)Dale4Saul2Red0 Wrote: ^

Vick better than Rivers is silly on a whole new level. Wasn't Vick's best season last year and it still didn't touch Rivers. Vick better than Roethlisberger? HOW??? Rings don't lie and neither do clutch performances.

You actually can't say Vick is clearly better than any of those guys. I think Roeth and Rivers are above everyone PhalconPhil mentioned with everyone else basically on the same level right now. Picking one over the other would be splitting hairs and they are all at different points in their careers too. Also I don't think 1 season from Vick should put him on that level. He faded last year. His type of QB takes a beating all season long and Vick is smaller than some of you realize. So my question to you is what good is a QB if he can't play his best football towards the end of the year because of the constant beating he takes?

Maybe it was said "in jest"

Dale4Saul2Red0 · 05-03-2011, 03:22 PM

I was asking a general question not directed toward anyone. Especially Phil for he was the one who made the list.

phalcon phil · 05-03-2011, 03:23 PM

(05-03-2011 03:09 PM)illmusic Wrote: Vick is better than Rivers? Lol, hell, Vick was better than Rivers this year?! Lololol

yes he was. in case you didn't notice. it was clearly brady, vick and then the rest of the league last year. those 2 were better than the rest.

pauliwood · 05-03-2011, 03:24 PM

(05-03-2011 03:18 PM)illmusic Wrote: Maybe it was said "in jest"

Well played

phalcon phil · (This post was last modified: 05-03-2011 03:26 PM by phalcon phil.)

or maybe yall are twisting my words.

go back, i said vick would be in the lower middle of the top ten overall

BUT IF IT WAS JUST BASED ON LAST YEAR, then yes vick was better than everyone but brady.

once again, reading comprehension is fundamental.

phalcon phil · 05-03-2011, 03:28 PM

(05-03-2011 02:48 PM)Dale4Saul2Red0 Wrote: Wait wait wait, so you allow fleas to dangle from your testicles? Am I safe in assuming you enjoy it then? Pretty unsanitary if you ask me. Guess I got those reading comprehension fundamentals down pat.

my 5 year old got more game than you son, that was hella weak