10 Most Overrated QB's in the Last Decade.

[Tandy]

(09-14-2010 04:34 PM)NZFalcon Wrote:  

(09-14-2010 04:29 PM)MattIceRyanMVP2 Wrote:  

(09-14-2010 04:26 PM)NZFalcon Wrote:  Mark Sanchez

Do you think there being fair to Sanchez? Don't get me wrong I don't like the guy but it's only his second season.


I know he has first round pick expectations but I don't think the spot light would burn as bright on him if his coach would keep his mouth shut.

He is hugely overrated but it is abit unfair on him.

One I think that is missing on the list in the Chiefs $63 million dollar man Matt Cassel

I said this before they took him. He will probably turn out to be a really good QB, I just thought they jumped the gun on him.

Of course, in my opinion, no player should get those kinds of contracts until they have proven themselves.

[Peyton]

(09-14-2010 04:38 PM)Tandy Wrote:  

(09-14-2010 04:34 PM)NZFalcon Wrote:  

(09-14-2010 04:29 PM)MattIceRyanMVP2 Wrote:  

(09-14-2010 04:26 PM)NZFalcon Wrote:  Mark Sanchez

Do you think there being fair to Sanchez? Don't get me wrong I don't like the guy but it's only his second season.


I know he has first round pick expectations but I don't think the spot light would burn as bright on him if his coach would keep his mouth shut.

He is hugely overrated but it is abit unfair on him.

One I think that is missing on the list in the Chiefs $63 million dollar man Matt Cassel

I said this before they took him. He will probably turn out to be a really good QB, I just thought they jumped the gun on him.

Of course, in my opinion, no player should get those kinds of contracts until they have proven themselves.

They have to fix the rookie salary scale, it's just rediculously out of hand. It actually makes teams sorry that they have a top 10 pick.

[NZFalcon]

Yea Matt Cassel's contract nowhere near fits the player he is (see I said is as he can still turn it around but going by last nights play that doesnt look like its happening this year)

[atl falcon 89]

Sanchez? Its only his second season and in his first he managed not to screw up enough to take his team to an AFC championship (pretty much all you can ask a rookie to do)

[Jesus]

(09-14-2010 03:49 PM)MattIceRyanMVP2 Wrote:  10. Donovan Mcnabb
9. Phillip Rivers
8. Eli Manning
7. Matt Hesselbeck
6. Daunte Culpepper
5. Carson Palmer
4. Vince Young
3. Jay Cutler
2. Michael Vick
1. Mark Sanchez




http://bleacherreport.com/articles/46208...de#page/12

McNabb took the Eagles to 5 conference championships and 1 SB appearance. I have a hard time thinking of any QB in the past 10 years who did that.
Rivers is the current holder of the best QB Rating in NFL History.
Manning Super Bowl win
Hassleback 3 pro bowls, 63-54 all time 26,000 yards
Culpepper was great until injuries and trading Moss killed him.

Can't argue the rest...Cutler should be #1. Give Sanchez another year to fizzle out. I don't see why Ryan and Flacco aren't on this list if Sanchez is.

[harveybirdman]

I would like to nominate another USC quarterback....


Matt Lienart.

[poutlipper]

(09-14-2010 03:49 PM)MattIceRyanMVP2 Wrote:  10. Donovan Mcnabb <-- No way
9. Phillip Rivers <-- No way
8. Eli Manning <-- No way
7. Matt Hesselbeck <-- Not sure how he is overrated?
6. Daunte Culpepper <-- Agreed, 3-4 year wonder thanks to Moss
5. Carson Palmer <-- Early in career, yes.
4. Vince Young <-- Hate to say it, but he wins games.
3. Jay Cutler <-- Agreed
2. Michael Vick <-- Due to inconsistency, agree.
1. Mark Sanchez <-- Too early.

I thought about letting this one go.. but of course I can't... and here's why:

26-27 - That's the overall record in playoff games by these guys. The only one to never play in the playoffs is Cutler. Now I know it's a team game, and it's not all on one player.

3 Super Bowl Appearances(only 1 ring).
11 Conference Championship Appearances

23 Pro-Bowl appearances between the 10 of them, each having been atleast once except Sanchez.

Now I've no idea how anyone can consider Mcnabb or Rivers overrated at all. I don't even think that's up for discussion. These are 2 of the best QB's of the last decade in my opinion. Hands down the 2 best on this list.

I also don't see how Eli makes this list either, as some pointed out, in the playoffs during their run, he was phenomenal. He's had 2 pretty good years in a row, especially last season which he played outstanding football.

[atl falcon 89]

(09-14-2010 10:41 PM)harveybirdman Wrote:  I would like to nominate another USC quarterback....


Matt Lienart.

Lineart's a big time college name who quickly turned into a bust sure, but as no one ever really rated very high for long, I'm not sure he cracks a top ten list.

[Jesus]

(09-15-2010 12:25 AM)atl falcon 89 Wrote:  

(09-14-2010 10:41 PM)harveybirdman Wrote:  I would like to nominate another USC quarterback....


Matt Lienart.

Lineart's a big time college name who quickly turned into a bust sure, but as no one ever really rated very high for long, I'm not sure he cracks a top ten list.

Its because he doesn't have Reggie Bush to push him into the endzone anymore.

[The Falcon Jedi]

Eli Manning cannot be considered Overrated. He won a SB.